About
Foundational Principles In the Community Diversity, Equity & Inclusion Technical Excellence Alumni TIAG Membership
Careers
Why Cohen & Company Our Culture Total Rewards & Benefits Intern & Entry Level Opportunities Experienced Opportunities
Contact
Akron, OH Baltimore, MD Chicago, IL Cleveland, OH Detroit, MI Milwaukee, WI New York, NY Philadelphia, PA Pittsburgh, PA St. Clair Shores, MI Youngstown, OH
Client Portal
Services Industries Knowledge Center People

About Our Services

We offer tailored solutions — whether private company or owner; public or private fund, adviser or fund service provider; or Fortune 1000 enterprise. Learn how we can help you.

Learn More

Assurance Services

Employee Benefit Plan Audits Internal Controls Investment Company Audits Private Company Audits SOC Readiness & Compliance

Tax Services

Federal Tax Planning & Compliance High Net Worth & Wealth Transfer International Filings & Structuring Investment Company Tax State & Local Tax Tax Credits & Incentives Transaction Tax Planning

Advisory Services

Business Valuations Data & Insights Digital Finance Solutions IT Strategy & Implementation M&A Advisory Outsourced Accounting Solutions Risk Assurance & Advisory Transaction Services Turnaround & Restructuring

Our Industry Expertise

Our industry experience means you can find professionals who speak your language and bring earned insights to the table. Learn how we can help you.

Learn More

Key Industries

Digital Assets Investment Companies Manufacturing Private Companies Private Equity Real Estate & Construction Technology & Life Science
VIEW THE COMPLETE LIST

Knowledge Center

Our team wants to help your team stay up to date. Browse our thought leadership, events and news for insights and a point of view on business-critical topics.

Learn More

Insights

Browse valuable articles and publications our experts have written to help you and your organization answer key questions — and consider new ones.

Read Our Insights

Events

Join us in person and online for events that address timely topics and key business considerations.

Explore Our Events

News

Find out what is happening at Cohen & Company, from industry recognitions and growth updates, to where we are contributing to important media stories.

Read Our News
People
Foundational Principles In the Community Diversity, Equity & Inclusion Technical Excellence Alumni TIAG Membership
Why Cohen & Company Our Culture Total Rewards & Benefits Intern & Entry Level Opportunities Experienced Opportunities
Akron, OH Baltimore, MD Chicago, IL Cleveland, OH Detroit, MI Milwaukee, WI New York, NY Philadelphia, PA Pittsburgh, PA St. Clair Shores, MI Youngstown, OH
Client Portal
Back to Insights

Supreme Court Overturns Quill Decision, Changes Sales Tax Landscape for All Retailers

by Hannah Prengler

June 22, 2018 State & Local Tax

June 21, 2018, marked the end of an era for retailers not charging sales tax. The Supreme Court’s 5-4 decision in South Dakota v. Wayfair, et al. favored states when it overruled the “physical presence” standard long held in Quill Corp. v. North Dakota. 

As a result states will now have more control over requiring any out-of-state business to collect sales tax — regardless if they have a physical presence in the state. This much-anticipated decision is poised to bring significant changes for all sellers.

The Decision 

Justice Kennedy delivered the opinion of the Court, which essentially confirmed what many states have been upset about for a long time — the explosive online retail environment of today makes the 1992 Quill standard of needing a physical presence to show significant business activity outdated. Specifically, Justice Kennedy noted that Quill’s physical presence standard is “unsound and incorrect” and that it served as a “judicially created tax shelter.” 

The four-prong test established in a previous case, Complete Auto Transit v. Brady, remains the standard to determine whether a state taxing statute is constitutional. The tax must:

  1. Apply to an activity with substantial nexus, or connection, to the taxing state;
  2. Be fairly apportioned;
  3. Not discriminate against interstate commerce; and
  4. Be fairly related to the services the state provides. 

The Quill case focused on the first prong, asserting that a physical presence was needed to satisfy the substantial nexus requirement. However, in Wayfair the Court found that the substantial nexus prong does not require physical presence, but instead can be satisfied if the entity conducts business in the state, online or otherwise. The Court found that the threshold South Dakota had imposed on Wayfair, which taxed the home store when it reached $100,000 in state sales or 200 or more separate transactions in the state, could only occur if the seller was conducting substantial business in the state, therefore satisfying the substantial nexus test.

The issue raised to the Court was very narrow and only addressed the physical presence requirement. The Court remanded the case to the South Dakota Supreme Court for further proceedings to address other Commerce Clause principles that could invalidate the South Dakota statute. Although the Court's decision did not officially address the validity of the statute under the remaining prongs of the Complete Auto Transit test, Justice Kennedy noted that the following aspects of the South Dakota law “appear designed to prevent discrimination against or undue burdens upon interstate commerce”:

  1. The $100,000/200 transaction threshold creates a safe harbor for sellers that transact only a limited amount of business in South Dakota.
  2. The Act cannot be applied retroactively.
  3. South Dakota adopted the Streamline Sales and Use Tax Agreement, which provides for simplified compliance.

What Taxpayers Should Do Now

Most importantly, DO NOT begin collecting sales tax in any jurisdiction until you are properly registered to remit the collected tax.

The Wayfair decision leaves many open questions and issues. What is the threshold that will satisfy substantial nexus? Would $1 or one transaction, as raised in oral arguments, be sufficient? The answer is likely no; however, it remains to be seen whether a state challenges the threshold amounts. 

Economic nexus statutes are not limited to South Dakota. Over one dozen states have enacted economic nexus statutes with thresholds similar to those found in the South Dakota statute. In many cases, these statutes have been stayed pending the outcome of Wayfair or pending state litigation. Now that the Wayfair decision has been issued, states will begin to enforce their own statutes and resolve pending litigation in the absence of the physical presence standard. The question as to when the statutes will become effective remains open. There is also uncertainty about the threshold in states that have dollar or transaction thresholds lower than those included in the South Dakota statute, such as the state of Washington, which currently imposes a very low $10,000 receipts nexus threshold.

The Wayfair decision likely will impact other areas of state and local tax. States began eroding the Quill physical presence standard for income tax purposes over 20 years ago. In recent years, we have seen more states adopt economic nexus and factor-presence standards for income tax purposes. The Wayfair decision likely will lead to legislation in states that previously applied the physical presence standard. Additionally, states that broadly define nexus as “doing business” in the state may become more active in asserting nexus over out-of-state taxpayers.

The Wayfair decision affects ALL sellers, not just online retailers. All sellers need to develop an action plan to determine how the Wayfair decision will impact their business. While it is likely that states will not immediately enforce existing sales tax economic nexus statutes, it is inevitable they will very soon. 

As you begin evaluating the new sales tax nexus landscape, you should initially consider the following: 

  1. Review your business’ 2017 sales by state reports to identify states in which you have more than $100,000 of sales. You also will need to review customer reports to determine if the 200 transactions threshold is exceeded in any state. 
  2. Review your current sales tax processes and procedures. Do you have processes in place to identify the taxability of the products/services you sell? Do you need to automate the taxability decision process? Also evaluate the impact on your current use tax procedures as vendors begin to collect.
  3. Review your customer exemption certificates and update as needed.
  4. Start discussions about sales tax compliance. Where will you need to register? Will you keep the compliance in house? If you prefer to maintain your compliance in house, should you automate your process?

Work with your state and local tax team to help you evaluate your current procedures and multi-state nexus thresholds, and to identify opportunities to reduce risk in non-filing states. It is imperative for sellers to understand their reporting and collection requirements and take steps to limit any further exposure based on the Wayfair decision. If a seller does not collect a required sales tax from their customer, the state will assess the seller for these taxes, along with interest and penalties.

Contact Hannah Prengler at hprengler@cohencpa.com or a member of your service team to discuss this topic further.

Cohen & Company is not rendering legal, accounting or other professional advice. Information contained in this post is considered accurate as of the date of publishing. Any action taken based on information in this blog should be taken only after a detailed review of the specific facts, circumstances and current law.
 

About the Author

Hannah Prengler, CPA

Partner, Tax
hprengler@cohencpa.com
216.774.1245

Sign Up for Our Emails & Events

Receive insights from our specialists in a variety of areas and timely information on upcoming events directly to your inbox as they go live in our online Knowledge Center.

Subscribe Today
Subscribe to our newsletter
About Contact Submit RFP Privacy Policy
LinkedIn Twitter Facebook
© 2023 Cohen & Company